Four In One [Pure DSD]

NativeDSD Blog Review

Veteran Dutch pianist-composer Misha Mengelberg and his longtime colleague, percussionist Han Bennink, made this date with Americans Dave Douglas and Brad Jones in Avatar Studios, NYC in 2000, at the dawn of the SACD era.

From the opening track, Mengelberg’s “Hypochristmutreefuzz”, which he and Bennink recorded with Eric Dolphy in 1964 just weeks prior to Dolphy’s untimely death, through a set of post-bop originals and Thelonious Monk tunes, this live-to-DSD recording captures the group’s sure-footed interactions — listen to the players turn on a dime from free blowing to a walking beat and swinging melodies in “Kneebus” – and the wide dynamics of Bennink’s huge percussion kit, a challenge for any recording engineer.

Standouts include an 8-minute reinterpretation of “Monk’s Mood” introduced by Brad Jones’ lyrical unaccompanied bass, and Mengelberg’s splendidly Monkish solo on his own “Blues after Piet”. Mengelberg, who died in 2017, was a champion of the works of Thelonious Monk and the unjustly neglected pianist-composer Herbie Nichols, and a co-founder of the Instant Composers Pool (ICP), a collective of European composer-improvisors. “Four in One” captures in the vivid sonics of DSD the energy of purposefulness and whimsical humor that Mengelberg and Bennink brought to their performances.

Mark Werlin - Source

All About Jazz

This session is a joyful combination of skilful musicianship and pixilated compositions. Mengelberg is heir to the Monk charm and perhaps Charles Mingus’ wit. His playing straddles Monk with his eclectic-European timing. Fans of both the ICP Orchestra and Douglas’s work will not be disappointed. Highly recommended.

Mark Corroto - Source

BBC Music

Throughout these players are a match made in Heaven. In Douglas, the group has a virtuoso with fire and stamina that doesn’t play for effect but for the music, as attuned to Stravinsky as much as Monk. The Dutchmen provide inspiration and challenge in equal measure. There’s a spirit and shared humour that’s infectious, beautifully exemplified by “Kwela P’Kwana” a rollicking tribute to the late lamented South African saxophonist Dudu Pukwana. Two Mengelberg compositions close this fine release; the Herbie Nichols-like “We’re going out for Italian” and “Poor wheel”. There can’t be many songs these days that are inspired by a squeaky wheel on a deux chevaux. More’s the pity; delightful stuff.

Ian R Watson - Source

AllMusic.com

(…) Misha Mengelberg has received much acclaim for everything from his solo performances to his leadership of the Dutch ICP Orchestra, but the small-ensemble recordings he began making in the U.S. during the ’90s are perhaps the best places to begin investigating his wonderfully offbeat charms. Four in One, recorded in September 2000 and subsequently released in the Hybrid Super Audio CD format by the Songlines label, is an album with particularly wide-ranging appeal, satisfying for listeners with tastes ranging from the avant-garde to more traditional post-bop, and certainly anyone interested in the commonality between Mengelberg and one of his primary influences, Thelonious Monk. (…)  Mengelberg projects an identity all his own, as he effortlessly redefines the possibilities of jazz with another tossed-off shrug.

Dave Lynch - Source

SoundStage!

This live-to-stereo-DSD recording is what we audiophiles want all SACDs to sound like. The musicians…are sonically portrayed with great vividness and a complete lack of electronic haze. Douglas’ trumpet has the perfect amount of bite, and the piano wafts through the soundstage with supreme clarity. You’ll need to goose the volume more than usual, but this will help you admire the wide dynamic range of this SACD all the more. The music is inventive and inspired, all of it composed by leader Mengelberg or Thelonious Monk, not the sleep-making jazz found on all too many audiophile recordings. This is one of the very best-sounding SACDs you can buy, which makes it one of the best-sounding recordings, period.

Marc Mickelson

Sound & Vision 4 out of 5

The relative obscurity of veteran Dutch pianist Mengelberg says something about the jingoism of American jazz fans and critics. Although his originality is apparent in every note, no other pianist captures as much of Thelonious Monk’s pinging rhythm and rhyme — perhaps because Mengelberg is guided by the same sort of thorny individuality. There are three Monk tunes on the terrific Four in One…Everything here is irresistible…The album benefits from Joe Ferla’s attentive engineering.

Francis Davis

Village Voice (Best Jazz CDs of 2002)

Dave Douglas’s muted, skittering phrases throughout this lively session contain some of his best work since Tiny Bell. His light-fingered trumpet tears through the first track, a ‘Freedom Jazz Dance’ meets ‘Hot House’ pastiche. Mengelberg’s piano responds in kind, and plies Monkian wit on a Monk triptych.

Gary Giddins

The Absolute Sound

A dozen years ago, Lester Bowie recorded an album called Serious Fun, which might serve well for this disc, too, though Misha Mengelberg & Co. drink more deeply from both parts of the title. Mengelberg is a Dutch pianist-composer whose style has roots in Monk, Mingus, Herbie Nichols, and the myriad streams of jazz and classical avant-garde – which is to say, his music is playfully witty, sometimes madcap, but more tightly structured than you might at first think…Douglas first joined forces with Mengelberg a few years ago, when he and his piano-less quartet learned a bunch of Mengelberg compositions (no easy task) and then asked the Dutchman himself to sit in with them at a live gig. On this disc, Douglas brings along the agile bass player from that date, Brad Jones. The result is a fresh blast of crazyquilt blues, ballads, circus tunes, and other bits beyond category, all of which swing like the proverbial demon. The three non-Mengelberg tunes, by the way, are Monk standards, which Mengelberg hurls in a funhouse where the mirrors elongate or compress the angles without ever rounding them off or — more amazing — losing Monk’s spirit. More wondrous still, if such were possible, is the sound…This ranks as one of the best digital jazz recordings ever – brash, airy, vivid, seamlessly spacious, with a black-curtain quiet backdrop…Joe Ferla is, once more, the man at the control board, again with tube mics, except for a ribbon mic on the trumpet and a couple dynamic spot mics on the tom-toms (a stereo tube mic over the trapset, though). He recorded live-to-2-track digital on Sony’s much-acclaimed DSD machine, which impressed Ferla greatly. Even so, he mixed it in analog on an old Neve console.

Fred Kaplan

Jazzweekly.com

…Mengelberg has, since the early 1960s, probably more than anyone else created what we think of as modern Dutch jazz…With a dash of experimental classical, a splash of American post bop and a lowlands infusion of comedic anarchy, he’s produced a hybrid Frankenstein monster that’s distinctive without scaring the pants off anyone…One of the clues to Mengelberg’s power is that he never takes anything — especially himself — too seriously. You can hear this in different sections of some tunes where his writing — and playing — can transform what sounds like a beginners’ piano exercise, a POMO polka, or a nursery rhyme into pulsating serious sounds. Another is his innate sense of disorderliness, which probably accounts for his 40-year plus partnership with Bennink, who has rarely seen a session he couldn’t disrupt…Freed from the responsibility of leadership, Douglas appears to be having time of his life…Joining the eight Mengelberg originals here are three Monk standards given the appropriate irreverent treatment…Mengelberg’s two-handed approach often out-Monks Monk…the Dutchman can slip in and out of tune and tempo so subtly that not one scintilla of the theme is lost. No one CD can ever be seen as being definitive, nor can exceptional Dutch jazz be illustrated in a single session of slightly more than 59 minutes. But Four in One gets awfully darn close.

Ken Waxman

The Penguin Guide to Jazz Recordings 4 out of 5

This is Mengelberg’s most completely satisfying record. The international group tackles the iconic bop of ‘Hypochristmutreefuzz’ (from Dolphy’s Last Date) with utter conviction. Other pieces, like ‘Kneebus’ and ‘Reef’, are also familiar from other records, but the real delight here is a sequence of Monk tunes placed in the middle of the album like the meat in a sandwich. It would be hard to differentiate between the originals and these classics, for Mengelberg makes ‘Four in One’, ‘Monk’s Mood’ and ‘Criss Cross’ entirely his own. Douglas is iin great form and Bennink shows once again what a fantastic ensemble player he is.