Note: the 5 Channel Surround Sound edition of Where is Pannonica? includes two free bonus tracks, Steve Coleman’s “Uhren” and Delbecq’s “Pyramides” in an alternate take with an alternate 5 Channel Surround Sound mix.
A piano duo project like no other, Where is Pannonica? brought together two longtime friends for a 3-week composing/recording residency at the Banff Centre, where they originally met in 1990 while studying with Steve Coleman. A commission from Chamber Music America’s French-America Jazz Exchange provided the impetus for this intensive exploration of the piano as a world of sound unto itself. During the process these two master performers, each with his own evolved style, discovered and nurtured a special affinity. Beyond a virtuosic exploration of extended pianistics and a cogent, highly entertaining presentation of improvisational intelligence, Where is Pannonica? is a step outside the box, opening onto barely explored conceptual and sonic realms of audio art.
Benoît Delbecq has synthesized sounds and concepts from Ligeti and Steve Lacy to Aka Pygmy music, while Andy Milne’s long association with Steve Coleman inspired a unique integration of rhythmic concepts from Cuba, Ghana, American jazz, funk and hip-hop. Their shared respect and understanding for each other’s approach to the piano and to improvisation helped connect them in a profound, almost seamless thought process throughout the collaboration. Interpreting each other’s compositions and creating pieces collaboratively, they developed complex rhythmic, melodic and harmonic relationships involving timbre and texture, room acoustics, space, and time.
The spatialization of the music is heard in its most complete form in the surround mix – in fact much of the music was composed specifically to exploit and draw inspiration from the sonic properties provided by the 5.0 format. In stereo too, each piece – and indeed the recording as a whole – is conceived as an ongoing dialogue between the instruments, the players, and the room. Extensive use of piano preparations transforms pitch and timbre, which are then continuously reorganized in rhythmic interplay from one pianist to the other. Milne comments: “When composing I tried to think of the 360 degrees of the room space and the more immediate space within and around each piano. For the intro to ‘Ice Storm’ I thought very consciously about creating compositional elements that would play with the sense of the space between the 2 pianos, using rhythm mostly, to create 5-channel imaging effects within the music.” On several pieces (e.g. the coda of “Divide Comedy”) Delbecq adds a shadowing, phantasmal element to the spatial aspects through the subtle use of electronics: “Dlooper is a Max-MSP stand-alone application, a multi-track looper that can superimpose 8 stereo channels, and output them on 8 different channels. I chose to play a stereo mix of those layers into speakers placed in the back of the concert hall, as if a radio were making comments on our statements, playing with the memory of what had just been played. The 5.0 microphone tree found itself being the ‘mixer’ – I was interested in having a stereo signal sent into speakers so as to artefact the room reflections and reverb.”
For more on the music and the process, check out the “making of” video at https://vimeo.com/7645082.
Andy Milne, Steinway D Piano
Benoît Delbecq, Steinway D Piano & Electronics (Tracks 3, 6, 11)
Tracklist
Please note that the below previews are loaded as 44.1 kHz / 16 bit.Total time: 00:51:30
Additional information
Label | |
---|---|
SKU | SGLSA15792 |
Qualities | |
Channels | |
Artists | |
Composers | |
Genres | |
Original Recording Format | |
Instruments | |
Release Date | March 24, 2025 |
Press reviews
Fred Hersch
“…a brilliant piece of work, amazing colors and soundscapes, and great sympatico…”
New York Times
“…a strangely beautiful new album…”
The Free Jazz Collective
“The Canadian and the French pianist are versatile in the most traditional environments, but their natural biotope is this creative modernism, with reminiscences to classical, but also inherently bluesy. Just listen to the playfulness of “Divide Comedy” as a reference, or “Water’s Edge”, with its fine African rhythms. Their style is rather minimalistic, almost pointillist at times, rather looking for the right note than for the long or powerful phrasing. Their use of extended techniques gives this great album some additional flavor.”
Allmusic
“The music is full of drama and unpredictable changes of mood, while never lapsing into pretentiousness. While the full CD is very satisfying, highlights include Milne’s intense “Ice Storm” and Delbecq’s eerie miniature “Task Sharing.” To appreciate its nuances, one must be immersed completely in this music without distractions.”
All About Jazz
“…this is a fascinating project, pushing the boundaries of the piano duo format. Using Steinway D grands that were often—mostly in Benoit Delbecq’s case—altered with prepared devices (objects on strings) and alternative playing techniques (strumming or hitting strings inside the piano), plus manipulating sounds with five-channel effects…the two musicians have created unique soundscapes while managing to maintain a dominantly pianistic approach…[evoking] memories of some of the more cerebral solo piano excursions of Ran Blake, Bill Evans and Fred Hersch. This is an album that demands a quiet room (or earphones) for listening. The effects are often very delicate and subtle, the pianos on the slower pieces played with a spare intensity that allows notes to float and recede slowly. Some tracks—”Task Sharing,” “Pyramides,” “Water’s Edge Part I”—are basically two-piano duets while others employ a panoply of altered piano sounds and electronic manipulations, from the wood block/marimba echoes and pluckings of “Divide Comedy” to the bowed-like drones, high-low contrasting textures and siren-like finale of “Mu-Turn.” A metallic, vibes-like timbre and harp-like strums compete with percussive textures and plain piano on “Water’s Edge Part II,” described as “water slowed down by frost” while “Part I” is a lively duet with one piano playing a rolling modern boogie while the other swoops and swirls cascades of notes around the rhythm. The full 51:50 minutes is more than the sum of its 11 tracks, making for a very satisfying and intriguing recital.”
Only logged in customers who have purchased this product may leave a review.

Reviews
There are no reviews yet.